I must admit that when I heard that our first novel was written in 1872 I was a little skeptical about whether or not I would like it. Generally, I do not enjoy historical writing; I have always preferred contemporary fiction with concepts that are translatable to my life and what I know. However this book has surprised me. While I do not love it nor would I choose to read it on my own, I do not find it a chore to read. sI actually might even enjoy it a little bit.
The first few pages were difficult to get through, but then as the drama ensued I began to think of it as a little telenovela. I have read a little bit of what others have blogged and I would have to agree that the characters are not very well developed and that the plot is a bit difficult to follow, however the melodrama is enough to keep me reading. While the novel is melodramatic it is also a very interesting commentary on the society in which Ruiz de Burton lived. I was most intrigued by the way she describes gender and power dynamics in the 19th century United States.
Ruiz de Burton exemplifies the way that women were perceived in that society by the comments made by male characters. Regardless of what the male characters say about women in that time, many of the female characters in the novel are strong and powerful women: Lavinia is a single woman of thirty-two who is a confident and capable of nursing. She is aware of how hard she works and she says this, however she still allows herself to be put down by Mr. Blower and she in turn also puts herself down. Mrs. Norval is a powerful and opinionated woman who demands respect and obedience, however she still allows Dr. Norval to make important decisions even if she does not agree with his choices. Ruiz de Burton offers an interesting look into the place of women in that society and how powerful men, such as the politicians with whom Lavinia and Mrs. Norval interact, perceive these women and shape their views of themselves.
Related to the gender dynamic illustrated in the novel is Ruiz de Burton’s commentary on reputation and power. She makes it very evident that one’s reputation is greatly affected by one’s political views, actions and friends or acquaintances. It is also clear that reputation is a big deciding factor for what advantages ares available to one in that society.
All in all I feel that this novel has done a good job of providing significant drama to keep me intrigued while also allowing me to learn a bit about 19th century society in the U.S. and the U.S. Civil War, topics about which I knew very little previously.
Suscribirse a:
Comentarios de la entrada (Atom)
7 comentarios:
Hi Heather. I agree that the gender dynamic is an interesting aspect of this book, not only in the interactions between the characters but in the circumstances of the novel's publication. Ruiz de Burton originally published the book anonymously - no matter how good the book was considered by her contemporaries, she feared that being Latina would disqualify her from writing in English and being female would disqualify her from making social criticisms.
-Serena
Hi Heather,
I believe we're definitely on the same page when it comes to the structure, and specifically, the beginning of the novel. I too was skeptical in thinking that the novel may not move at a very fast pace and perhaps be tedious, but I find it a fairly easy read, and am lightly enjoying it.
I think that Ruiz de Burton's underlying, or perhaps evident attack on the gender issues in 19th century United States is fairly well done. I also fully agree when it comes to the personality traits of Lavinia and Mrs. Norval. Perfect examples of 19th century women, and the battles they face as a sex.
Great comments!
-Kaan
Hey Heather,
I must admit that I was also intrigued by the way Ruiz de Burton described power and gender in her novel,especially in regards to Lavinia. I also perceive her as a strong woman, but one whose conscience can be easily shaped by those around her. To me, it is odd to think that Lavinia, at 32, was thought of as such an "old maid" at that time who had no hope at all to marry or have children. I'm aware that the life-expectancy rate was probably lower, and that gender-equality in the US was not at the same level, but I really can't imagine that being 32, single, and having skills as a nurse would be looked down on today in North America. Great Blog!
-Deanna
Hi Heather,
I agree about thinking this book wouldn't have issues that I would be able to relate to, however, I'm finding that besides for the historical aspects of the book, many of the relationships are quite like today's, albeit a little less harsh.
Its quite interesting to see how women were treated back in thsoe days and even the hiarchical structure of power within the women themselves.
hey babe, i didnt really think of the gender dynamics between the males and females through the female roles. only how the men perceived them. i like the fact that you showed that the females in the novels are very strong and (in their time) independent women. thanks!
If you enjoy reading contemporary fiction because it relates and translates to your own life then you should consider rethinking why you dislike historical or older books. Humans constantly repeat their mistakes throughout time and therefore lessons become timeless. Although we may not be arguing over Lola's dowry, conflicts concerning race and gender are still prevalent today and will be until the end of time.
They do however take more effort to read, i can agree with you on that.
I agree with a lot of the things you have mentioned. i was not excited to read this book knowing it was written in the 19th century. I had a hard time getting into it, but now i like it. I think Ruiz de Bruton has done a great job portraying gender, race and class issues through this drama, which makes it a bit exciting to read! It's funny I don't see Leviana as independent and strong... I see her frustrated and desperate, but that might be because i haven't read further into the book.
Delara
Publicar un comentario